Let’s run through what to consider when shopping for a supportive pillow, plus eight highly vetted options that won’t be a pain in your neck. One thing to note about Tempur-Pedic pillows is that they do tend to be quite heavy and aren’t as easy to travel with. And for those looking for a cushier feel, they will be too firm. While Tempur-Pedic offers a five-year limited warranty, they don’t accept returns, so you might want to try this one out in person before placing your order. The only downside to this pillow is the synthetic materials: You’ll find memory foam in its inner shell and some polyester in its cover. However, for those who aren’t determined to go organic, it’s an affordable option worth checking out. Beyond using organic materials, Avocado also supports the environment with carbon-negative production and shipping. While the filling in this pillow is synthetic, the foam is at least certified by GREENGUARD and CertiPUR-US to be low in VOC emissions and less harmful to health. Made from certified organic latex from rubber sap trees and a washable organic cotton cover, it’s an earth-friendly pillow that gets shipped in a reusable, organic cloth bag to minimize plastic waste. Beyond being sustainable, latex is a naturally breathable and supportive material that holds shape over time. This pillow gets super-high marks; out of hundreds of reviews, you won’t find anyone who rated it with a single star. The main complaint is that it only comes in one size. While this pillow is firmer than most down pillows, reviewers note that it is still definitely on the softer side, so those who need extra support will want to look elsewhere. Down, while a natural material, also tends to lose its shape faster than memory foam or latex. The Elite Rest is encased in a machine-washable cotton cover, but the pillow itself is made from synthetic memory foam.
